Speaking to reporters, the minister said meaningful engagement was possible only if both sides were willing to listen to each other’s views.
On the JAC’s demand for shifting the project to an alternative location, Lyngdoh maintained that the ropeway was planned for a specific site and could not simply be relocated.
According to the minister, the project has already secured clearances from five central ministries, and shifting the proposed alignment would effectively undo the work undertaken so far.
He also noted that no objections had been raised during his earlier two-and-a-half-year stint as Tourism Minister, beginning in 2023.
With the two sides holding firm to their respective positions, the dispute over the Shillong Peak Ropeway continues without an immediate breakthrough.
Tourism Minister says shifting alignment would require fresh clearances; open to talks with protesters under specified conditions
SHILLONG, Nov 14: The Meghalaya government has ruled out relocating the Shillong Peak Ropeway project despite sustained opposition from the Joint Action Committee (JAC), with Tourism Minister Paul Lyngdoh on Saturday asserting that the project is site-specific and shifting its alignment would require the entire approval process to be initiated afresh.
While maintaining that the government’s doors remain open to dialogue with the protesters, Lyngdoh made it clear that discussions must take place in an atmosphere of mutual respect, without sloganeering or disruptions, effectively ruling out any immediate reconsideration of the project’s location.
Speaking to reporters, the minister said meaningful engagement was possible only if both sides were willing to listen to each other’s views. Recalling a recent outreach initiative by senior Cabinet colleague Sanbor Shullai, he said the meeting with invited JAC members had turned into a protest rather than a constructive discussion.
“When people only shout themselves hoarse to the point that nothing else can be heard, then there is absolutely no point for discussion,” Lyngdoh said, adding that discussions at that level should be free from emotional outbursts and that participants must be prepared to listen to the government’s position as well.
On the JAC’s demand for shifting the project to an alternative location, Lyngdoh maintained that the ropeway was planned for a specific site and could not simply be relocated. He said moving the alignment would mean restarting the regulatory process, including obtaining fresh clearances from central ministries and undertaking soil tests, vegetation studies and preliminary surveys.
According to the minister, the project has already secured clearances from five central ministries, and shifting the proposed alignment would effectively undo the work undertaken so far.
Questioning the timing of the opposition, Lyngdoh pointed out that the project was initiated in 2022, with the Memorandum of Understanding signed during the first Meghalaya Democratic Alliance (MDA-I) government’s tenure, before he entered the Assembly. He also noted that no objections had been raised during his earlier two-and-a-half-year stint as Tourism Minister, beginning in 2023.
“Why the sudden dissent? Why the sudden protest?” he asked.
Defending the project’s economic potential, Lyngdoh said the ropeway would strengthen Shillong’s position as a tourist destination and generate wider benefits for other popular attractions, including Sohra, Mawlynnong, Laitlum and Sweet Falls, through increased tourist footfall.
The JAC, meanwhile, has been opposing the project over concerns relating to environmental impact, tree felling and the lack of adequate consultation, while demanding that the proposed alignment be shifted or the project reconsidered.
Lyngdoh’s latest remarks indicate that although the government is willing to hear the protesters’ grievances, it is unwilling to reopen the question of the project’s location. With the two sides holding firm to their respective positions, the dispute over the Shillong Peak Ropeway continues without an immediate breakthrough.